Saturday, 9 February 2013

Weekly Crude and WTI Oil Market Summary: Brent-WTI premium back to November levels


4th – 8th February


WTI suffered this week as the Brent-WTI premium widened significantly to $23.2. The US blend, which fell -2.1% from its previous weekly close, suffered as traders continued to speculate as to the time frame in which WTI delivery to refiners would finally be free from constraints. Brent meanwhile came under pressure from improving economic fundamentals as well as a Goldman Sachs warning that prices were likely to be higher than forecasts this quarter. The grade finished the week at $118.9, 1.8% higher than its previous weekly close.











Weekly Summary

Monday started negatively for both Brent and WTI, with the former gapping down $0.4 to $116.4 and the latter gaping down $0.2 to $97.6. This negative sentiment gained momentum throughout the day due on economic news, with reports from France’s El Pais newspaper claiming the ruling Spanish party had received unauthorised funds, thus adding more uncertainty in the much beleaguered European country and thus the euro zone. Elsewhere news from Iran’s foreign minister stating that Iran would consider bilateral negotiations over Iran’s nuclear program resulted in a drop in risk premium in prices. While Brent fell -0.7%, WTI was hit hardest in line with declining US equities, although some of this drop could have been in response to overbought technical indicators on the back of last week’s strong gains.

Oil rebounded on Tuesday as economic indicators for service sector activity in both the US and Europe came in as positive. Given Monday’s negative European sentiment, the news was particular welcome and provided strength to the euro which appreciated versus the USD, thereby making oil more attractive to European buyers. Brent continued to outpace WTI as traders awaited the results of the API industry report on crude stocks, with the North Sea grade gaining 0.9% versus 0.6% for WTI. This price differential resulted in the Brent-WTI premium topping $20 for the first time this year, ending the UK trading day at $20.1, but dropping below the $20 mark in the US after the API survey showed stocks at Cushing fell to the lowest point this year.

Trading on the day of the weekly EIA oil report resulted in little change in WTI while Brent increased 0.2%. As the breakdown in my weekly EIA analysis explains, a decline in stocks at Cushing was enough to offset an overall increase in inventories and negative demand signs in breakdown of the EIA report. Brent may have seen some upward pressure from a tightening of sanctions on Iran, while negative effects from a slight USD appreciation would have offset positive effect from a slight rise in USD equities.

The Brent-WTI premium carried on rising on Thursday as media outlets reported that work on one of the crude processing units at BP’s Whiting, Indiana refinery would not be ready until July, 3 months later than expected. The consequences of this 260,000 barrel a day unit not being available means stocks in Cushing will be under even further pressure than previously thought, and the WTI price fell -1%. Adding to the spread differential were two main points of news out of the Middle East; firstly a Gulf official stated output there had fallen to its lowest level since May 2011 at 9.05 mb/d, and secondly the Iranian Supreme Leader stated that the country would be unwilling to take part in the bilateral negotiations with the USA that had seemed possible earlier on in the week. While the former affected oil market fundamentals, the latter also added to the risk premium, and Brent rose 0.3%. The fact that Saudi production has continued to fall to new lows shows signs Saudi is intent on keeping the oil price high, and so many analysts may raise their annual Brent price forecasts.

Trade data showing 25% y/y export growth came out of China early Friday morning, while the breakdown showed crude inputs had risen to the highest level in 8 months. Positive momentum for Brent followed and the grade maintained its velocity throughout the day, increasing 1.2% to close at a 9 month high of $118.9. Added to the upward pressure was a release by Goldman Sachs predicting oil markets would remain tight in Q1 and prices were likely to be above forecasts; such releases from the banking giant usually create a trend, and a notable point of the release was their view that the price had increased purely on fundamentals rather than incorporating a further risk premium. Trading sentiment for the US crude remained negative, and WTI failed to be boosted by the momentum affecting Brent and the grade fell 0.1% to close at $95.7. While some positive was taken by data showing increasing US crude exports last month, the Brent-WTI spread nevertheless rose by a further $1.5, closing the week at $23.2, a level not seen since 22nd November.

Week Ahead

As predicted in last week’s weekly summary, WTI prices did indeed fall this week, although the extent of the Brent-WTI spread widening has been massive due to a resounding week for crude prices. The Brent-WTI spread has now increased every day for 8 days, since the announcement of capacity restrictions on the Brent-WTI spread. I’ll be addressing this issues again in another post later today, to give a more detailed insight on how the spread could develop over the coming months.
Brent prices are particularly elevated at the moment, and for now the most important things to look out for this week will be further news regarding Iran, further data showing economic fundamentals improving and signs regarding inventories at Cushing. If Cushing inventories decrease, we should see WTI rebounding to some extent, but lack of significant positive news would result in Brent retracing after its huge momentum on Friday. Overall we could see a slight decrease in the prices of both grades this week.

Thursday, 7 February 2013

Weekly WTI Crude Oil Inventory Analysis: EIA release of 6th February



Summary of last weeks’ change in Crude Inventories figures:

API: +3.6 mb

EIA Consensus:  +3 mb (Platts)

EIA actual: +2.6 mb

A fall in inventories at Cushing was the highlight of this week’s EIA report, with stocks falling by 315,000 barrels at the Oklahoma terminal. Despite rising crude stocks nationwide and a report that contained a number of negative factors, crude was nevertheless mainly buoyed by this positive regional highlight and both WTI and Brent prices increased in the hours after the release.

The Breakdown

Refinery activity remained subdued last week, with utilisation rates falling -0.8%pts to 84.2% and gross crude inputs decreasing by -132,000 b/d. While utilisation rates are typically low this time of year due to seasonal maintenance, the numbers are nevertheless negative for short-term crude demand.

Total petroleum products supplied to the market saw a large fall of 629,000 b/d (-3.4%), but this was mostly attributed to propane and “other oils” (see EIA for definitions). The more commonly followed gasoline, which accounts for approximately 47% of total petroleum products supplied, saw a more modest decrease of -86,000 b/d (-1%), although this nevertheless was bad news considering the current large stocks of gasoline held. Indeed, inventories of gasoline increased by a further 1.738 mb last week, with the decreasing trend in stocks from the previous two weeks unable to be maintained.

Some respite came from a decrease in imports by 499,000 b/d in conjunction with another week in which US crude production remained fairly stable, increasing by just 4,000 b/d. The most positive sign for US crude prices came from stocks at Cushing, which declined by 315,000 barrels to reach a one-month low. This was despite news last week that the Seaway pipeline from Cushing to Texas had not been operating at full capacity due to bottlenecks in the system. Media reports that this drop in inventories could therefore have been due to buyers now using rail to transport crude, and companies such as PBF Energy have been increasing rail capacity at its refineries, as reported by Bloomberg.

How Markets Reacted

Both grades were on slightly negative trajectories in the short period up to the EIA release, with WTI facing a steeper downward trend then Brent in anticipation of further increases in inventories. Although such an increase did materialise, the fact that stocks at Cushing actually fell last week demonstrated that the negative market reaction to last week’s news Seaway pipeline capacity news may have been too strong, and WTI in particular rebounded.

The April contract for WTI was priced around $92.10 around 15:30 on Wednesday, and after the release began an upwards trend that resulted in an increase of about $0.70 in the following half an hour, with the grade reaching $97.30 before it started to retrace as traders took profits.



Brent struggled to trade convincingly in either direction in the first 10 minutes after the release, but soon began an upward trend in line with WTI. In total the grade managed a gain of around $1 before also retracing around 17:00 GMT.


Next week’s release

In previous weeks we have seen demand side signals from products supplied and refinery inputs overshadow large build-ups in inventories, with much of the inventory build-up deemed to be down to seasonal factors. Following this logic we may have expected a fall in oil this week as product demand and refinery input declined, but instead market sentiment seemed to be focused on signs that inventories at Cushing had decreased to a one month low. Having said this, US equities were also experiencing a positive day which may have explained some of the gain in oil. The key therefore to look out next week will be how inventories at Cushing have developed now rail is beginning to play a key factor, and if overwhelming supply can  once again be overshadowed by positive signs that this supply is at least making it to customers.

Monday, 4 February 2013

Brent and WTI crude oil price forecasts: 2013 Summary and Projections


Whether you are a short-term trader or long term investor, it’s good to have an idea of where markets could be heading and what events will be the key drivers of market change. Hence in this article I’ll be looking at the possible determinants of oil prices in the remaining 11 months of 2013 and take a look to see where analysts are predicting oil prices will head over the year.

Current Forecasts

Analysts generally forecast prices a couple of years out, but given the large number of unpredictable events that affect macroeconomics and politics, these forecasts often change. The table below demonstrates these changes, showing that forecasts of the 2013 Brent price by analysts polled by Reuters fluctuated up and down over the second half of the year, with the average prediction now standing at $109.7, $3.70 down from the current price of $113.50. Given this is an annual projection, it means most analysts predict prices will fall below $109.7 at some point.

Mean forecast
Aug-12
$107.2
Sep-12
$106.9
Oct-12
$108.8
Nov-12
$107.5
Dec-12
$108.0
Jan-13
$109.7

What should you make of these forecasts, and how have they been formed? Given the average yearly price is forecast to be less than the current prices, let’s begin with a look at what could cause a fall in Brent and WTI prices.

Booming US production

EIA data show US oil production has been accelerating a record rate, and the increase in production last year outstripped the growth in pipeline capacity, causing the much talked about supply glut at Cushing, Ok and leading to the capacity upgrade and reversal of a pipeline that previously flowed into Cushing. As the graph below shows, production has increased from around 5 mbd to 7 mbd in the last 5 years, with the majority of this growth coming in 2012, when production increased around 14% y/y from Jan-Nov compared to 2011. With EIA expecting US production to continue to grow by another 0.9 mb/d in 2013 (Table 1, an increase of 14%) we could see downward pressure on WTI due to increased supply as well as downward pressure on Brent due to decreased US demand for imports. Such developments are already being noticed; last week Hess announced a closing of a New Jersey refinery that still relied on Brent imports due to increased costs of the North Sea blend versus the WTI blend, which should reduce import demand. This is combined with the fact we have already seen US crude oil imports decreasing in the last few months. Furthermore, in an announcement last week Seaway pipeline operators Enterprise confirmed that the increased capacity was unable to be utilized to full effect due to new bottlenecks in supply in Texas, with these not expected to be alleviated until 2H2013. Thus if increased US production does arise then a lot of this is unlikely to be able to reach refineries and thus increased storage costs will weigh on the price

Other non-OPEC production is expected to rise

The EIA also expects large gains in crude production in other non-OPEC countries, with the agency forecasting total non-OPEC crude and liquid fuels supplies to rise by 1.42 mb/d to 53.89 in 2013. Accounting for the US, this means there should be growth of around 0.5 mb/d a day in other non-OPEC countries, with potential sources of growth including South Sudan, Brazil and Kazakhstan. South Sudan would be the area where supplies could come on-line the soonest, with the current lack of supply a result of a dispute between South Sudan and Sudan over how much the Southern country should have to pay to transport oil through pipelines in the North. If solutions are found and production reaches the pre-shutdown rate there would be an extra 350,000 bd on the market.  Elsewhere, Kazakhstan’s new oilfield Kashagan is expected to reach 150,000 bd by the middle of the year. However as the FT reports, projects in Kazakstahn have been beset with problems and even reaching 150,000 bd would be a success at this stage.

In September the EIA suggested Brazil’s output could grow by up to 200,000 b/d in 2013 due to its offshore, pre-salt fields which could contain reserves equal to those found in the North Sea. Production growth has been slow however due to strict legislation by the Brazilian government aimed at ensuring Brazil gets its fair share of the profits. This included the halting of production & exploration licenses in 2008, resulting in foreign companies having to take the slow process of merging with companies already in possession of licenses in order to gain opportunities for growth. A long awaited auction is now scheduled for May and could result in further Brazilian developments in the second half of 2013, although these issues demonstrate that there may not be considerable Brazilian growth this year.

Upside Risks

While increased production remains the significant downside risk for crude prices, there are a number of factors that could result in crude prices continuing to rise after already increasing in January. These include:

A higher risk premium from geopolitical tensions

The current risk-premium priced into Brent is believed to be between $10-$20. While this premium could rise or fall, there are a number of issues concerning the Middle East and Africa that could add a further premium; this article at oilprice.com provides a narrow summary. This list is not exhaustive however, and a potentially huge problem would be a further breakdown in relations between the Kurdish regional government and the Iraqi central government over long-running tensions that have been further fueled by the regional government signing independent contracts with international oil companies, eager to secure additional supply in the face of high prices. Currently the central government is threatening to withdraw fiscal payments to the area, and readers who want to learn more on this issues should see this Time article as a great starting point, as well as this article at Foreign Policy in Focus for further information.

At the top of the risk-premium agenda will be continued issues between Iran and the Western international community, with current sanctions against Iran reducing exports from 2.2 to 1.4 mb/d according to Reuters. There has been much speculation that military action by Israel against nuclear facilities could be possible, and one of Iran’s main tactical advantages is controlling the Strait of Hormuz, which carries 17.5 mbd of oil supplies from the Middle East to Europe and beyond. While other avenues for crude out of the region exist and are being developed further, the current situation has resulted in Iran threatening to close the Strait in the event of military intervention, and US threatening intervention only if Iran closes the Strait. The problem here would be antagonistic action by other countries such as Israel in the belief that this would push the US to get involved. Today the country did announce it will be meeting directly with the US on February 25th, so this is the next date to look out for.

Saudi Arabia will cut production

With many members of OPEC counting on oil revenues to fund their budgets, the cartel has tended to keep a minimum Brent price floor. For the first half of 2012 this was thought to be $100, however at a June meeting OPEC communicated that this could comfortably rise to $110 without damaging global growth, and reaffirmed this at the latest meeting in December . While the cartel confirmed that it would maintain a production ceiling of 30 mb/d, about 1 mb/d above its production at the time, the group also said it believed demand for its oil would fall to 29.7 mb/d in 2013 and data released in early January show Saudi Arabia had actually already began reducing their output in December. Although there have been suggestions that this could just be due to seasonal demand issues.

Economic growth in the US and China will accelerate

The effect of macroeconomic expectations for the USA on oil prices was demonstrated over the New Years when politicians voted to avert the so-called fiscal cliff on December 31st, resulting in the WTI price increasing 3% over the two days of trading on 31st December and 2nd January. Given that the last few weeks have seen a number of economic indicators and corporate earnings in both the US and China come in better than expected, many market commentators are now suggesting this could finally be a return to something like pre-crisis growth levels, and thus oil prices would come under further pressure from increased demand.

Oil will increase in line with US equities

This point relates indirectly to above, but argues that potential negative supply factors will be overwhelmed by oils increasing position as an investment asset. As the EIA reports here, correlations between oil and other factors have become increasingly stronger. In particular, since 2008 oil has shown an increasing correlation with US equities and inflation expectations as well as a negative correlation with the USD. Some believe this is because oil is increasingly being seen as an investment asset; hence if equities are rising on economic expectations then oil demand is expected to increase and investment in oil contracts increase too. A negative correlation is seen with the USD as a weaker dollar makes oil cheaper for non-US investors, as well as raising inflation expectations in the US which causes investors there to seek assets that will increase with inflation such as commodities.

Summary and Forecast

With the announcement last week that the Seaway Pipeline has not been able to operate effectively due to storage capacity constraints, I do not see how WTI prices can continue to increase in the first half of the year, particularly if US production does grow as much as analysts are expecting. While I expect prices to rise in the second half of the year on the back of growth and the completion of further storage infrastructure, I nevertheless expect a slight decrease in the average WTI price from what it is now, to somewhere in the $90-$95 range.

For Brent the situation is a bit more tricky. If the geopolitical risk premium remained the same, I would expect at least that the Brent price would not fall much from its current level as global growth offsets some increase in supply, which would also be balanced out by less Saudi production. Having said that, it’s highly unlikely that the risk premium will not change when we have upcoming events in February regarding Iran to look out for. My view would be that the price could fall if these issues look positive, resulting in an average 2013 Brent price of $110 - $115.

Lastly it’s important to remember that prices of any asset class or commodity are difficult to forecast, with oil notably difficult due to the myriad of events that can affect both demand and supply. For an interesting article on how analyst’s forecasts have performed historically, check out this article at risk.net.

Weekly Inventory Analysis: EIA release of 30th January

Summary of last weeks’ change in Crude Inventories figures:


API: +4.2 mb
EIA Consensus:  +2.5 mb
EIA actual: +5.9 mb

Brent and Crude traded choppily last Wednesday on the back of an EIA release that saw crude inventories rise +3.4 mb above the expected number. Despite positive signs from refiners and consumers, the continuing rises in inventories in the US and in particular Cushing show that supply factors may be beginning to dominate once more.

The Breakdown

After the previous release showed a massive drop in refinery utilisation, it was a relief to see the gauge increase 1.4%ppts to 85% this week, with refinery inputs also increasing by 275,000 b/d after last week’s large fall. While the long term average utilisation rate is around 88.7%, it is normal to see lower rates at this time of the year.

Further positive signs were seen from a second consecutive fall in gasoline stocks as well as a fall in distillate stocks, which when combined with further increases in the demand figures for these two types of product points to signs that refinery utilisation and thus crude demand could continue to increase in next week’s release. 

Despite these positive signs, negative indications came from a rise in net imports and the fact that day’s inventory cover seemed to be ticking up at a faster rate than normal for this time of year: Net imports increased by 338,000 b/d, more than making up for the fall seen last week, while day’s supply, which measures how many days of crude demand current inventories could cover for, reached 25 days last week. This measure is typically cyclical as the chart below shows; however the black line indicates cover appears to be increasing sooner than usual, which demonstrates the extent to which supply is overwhelming demand at the moment.



Finally, despite these signs of overwhelming supply there was some consolation from that fact that US production remained roughly flat for the second week running, with production increasing just 4,000 b/d.

How Markets Reacted

Wednesday was a significant news day for crude, with both US GDP and a Federal Reserve meeting scheduled as well as continuing concerns of geopolitical events in the Middle East rearing their head. Under this backdrop, trading was choppy for the whole day but news outlets suggest an underlying negative sentiment from the inventories release despite the fact that prices for both grades increased.
WTI was priced around $98 at 15:30 on Wednesday, and as the graph below shows the bulls and bears fought for control of the market as the grade rose, slipped and then rose again so that by 16:00 it had actually increased to around $98.1 despite the negative headline number.



Brent saw similar action as the chart below shows, increasing by around $0.3 from around $113.3, before falling back down and then rising again. While Brent then seemed to increase slightly, this could be put down to geopolitical issues as news was released that French forces had hit a weapons convoy in Syria at a similar time on Wednesday (see Weekly Oil Summary).



This week’s release

The fact that this summary is a little late allows me to include reference to news late last week that it has been confirmed that the Seaway Pipeline has not been as effective as suggested at alleviating the WTI glut seen in Cushing. While some extra capacity on the pipeline has been used, we are now in the situation where one of the exit points at Jones Creek, TX has reached its storage capacity (see Weekly Oil Summary), and the pipeline has thus not been able to operate at the increased throughput of 400,000 bd. While WTI decreased 0.5% on this news, further negative news regarding inventories this week could see a much stronger reaction from the WTI price. While demand signs will continue to be a key focus for Brent, we could see a further disconnection between the two grades if inventories at Cushing are indeed seen to be increasing further, particular if US crude production begins another upward trend.

Sunday, 3 February 2013

Weekly Crude and WTI Oil Market Summary: WTI-Brent spread widens on Seaway issues

28th January – 1th February

Weekly Summary

Continued signs of macroeconomic recovery in the US on Monday provided a continuation of momentum from last week, and WTI and Brent both saw gains. Brent, which had opened at $113.3, increased 0.2% while WTI rose 0.5% from its opening price of $95.9. Positive data came from signs of increased business orders, a proxy for investment, although gains were pared by signs that pending house sales had fallen. News that integrated oil company Hess was to close its last refinery in the US, located in New Jersey, also boosted gasoline prices which led to rises in WTI. As this article reports, such refiners are unable to access much of the domestically produced oil due to their location away from key pipelines and therefore have still been relying on the more expensive Brent-indexed imports to produce gasoline. Unable to compete on costs, the refinery has closed and there is an expectation that more WTI- produced gasoline will be required to meet the lost supply. There was also a slight rise in the risk premium after further terror attacks against an Algerian pipeline as well as reports out of Iran on Saturday stating the government would give military support to Syria against any Western intervention there.

Positive economic momentum continued on Tuesday, with US house price data showing a tenth month of rising house prices which led to significant gains in US equities and an improving perception of future oil consumption demand. The situation in Europe was also given a boost by the first rise in German consumer confidence in four months. On this positive news Brent increased 0.8% while WTI gained 1.1%, with the WTI-Brent spread narrowing by $0.2 to $16.8.

Despite US GDP coming in at a surprise negative -0.1% and EIA inventories increasing more than expected, both grades gained on the day in the face of improving sentiment in Europe, increased political risk in the Middle East and as the dollar weakened after the monthly Fed meeting.  Markets reacted negatively to news that crude inventories had risen +5.9 mb versus a consensus of +2.5 mb, but oil soon pared losses as the Fed announced a continuation of asset purchases, which led to a weakening of the dollar and thus an increase in the attractiveness of oil for those outside of the US. This was reinforced by a French news report that Israel had attacked a Syrian weapons convoy, thus creating the possibility of retaliation attacks against Western-backed targets.

Thursday saw what was almost a delayed reaction to the Wednesday EIA inventories report, which in conjunction with an announcement from Seaway Pipeline operator Enterprise, led to WTI falling -0.5%. The pipeline is facing trouble because despite increasing the pipeline capacity, the glut has now built to such an extent at the end of the line at Jones Creek that pipeline through-put has had to be curtailed as there is no spare storage capacity. Although this has been affected by a temporary closure of a refinery in the area, it shows just how high supply is that even temporary scheduled maintenance is having a large effect on the ability of companies to shift crude. 

Despite news that a new pipeline and storage facilities will come on during the year, it appeared some traders were closing out of position that were set up to bet on the spread narrowing. Closing out of such a long-WTI, short Brent Position, would put negative pressure on WTI and positive pressure on the Brent price. As such, WTI fell -0.5% and Brent increased 0.6%.

Friday saw positive news from the US from an increase in the US non-farm payrolls number. While WTI increased 0.2%, Brent saw a higher rise 0.9% on further geopolitical issues coming from a suicide attack at the US embassy in the Turkish capital of Ankarra. Reuters also cited further exits of the WTI-Brent spread trades as reason for Brent rising further than the US blend, as traders had time to further consider the implications of pipeline news on Thursday. On this the WTI-Brent spread widened further and closed the week at $19, having increased by $2 in two days, with WTI at $97.8 and Brent at $116.8.

Week Ahead: WTI to fall?

The big news last week was certainly the fact that the Seaway Pipeline will be nowhere near as effective as thought in reducing the glut of WTI supply. We saw the spread at around $19 at the beginning of January, just before the increased capacity came in to place. The spread has already returned to this point, closing at $19 on Friday. However it’s important to note that WTI is at a price of $97.8 now versus about $92 at the beginning of the year. Although there has been an increased risk premium, the more the WTI glut builds up the less the risk premium will be reflected in the WTI price as the majority of the product will just not be moveable, and will instead be subject to increased costs from higher demand for storage. Although the macroeconomic signs are strong, supply fundamentals have to overcome sentiment at some point, and I would expect to see deterioration in the WTI price this week, which would be the first fall in 9 weeks. A point of great interest would be if this fall is combined with a rise in the Brent risk premium dependent on geopolitical issues this week, which would imply a widening of the WTI-Brent spread.

Sunday, 27 January 2013

Weekly Crude and WTI Oil Market Summary: WTI-Brent spread widens on limited Seaway capacity

21th – 25th January

A climb of 0.3% for WTI meant a 7th consecutive weekly gain this week, making it the longest upward trend in the grade since 2009. While both WTI and Brent benefitted from upbeat, albeit tentative, macroeconomic signs in the US and China, WTI suffered mid-week due to problems with the Seaway Pipeline out of Cushing. A 1.3% weekly gain for Brent meant a second weekly rise in the WTI-Brent spread, which now stands at $17.4, up from $16.3 the week before.

Weekly Summary

WTI opened at $95.9 and Brent at $111.8 on what turned out to be a relatively slow news day on Monday. Given it was Martin Luther King Jr day in the US, trading volumes were particularly low. Meanwhile, traders were awaiting outcomes from a meeting of EU finance ministers in Brussels and the result of a Bank of Japan (BoJ) meeting in Tokyo. Overall there was no strong direction in either grade; WTI increased 0.1% while Brent declined -0.1%.

While the announcement came late on Monday night, it was not until Tuesday that markets could react to the announcement from the BoJ that the Bank would be engaging in monetary stimulus policy, committing to purchasing $145 million of assets a month in a similar programme to those seen in the US and the UK. The BoJ hopes that this will stimulate demand and inflation in Japan, which accounts for 5% of the world’s oil demand. While an announcement was expected, it was the open-ended nature of the purchase commitment that particularly buoyed markets.  The positive momentum from this announcement continued in the day as a number of economic surveys also saw positive results, with the German ZEW indicator of economic confidence  climbing to its highest level since May 2010 and a Bloomberg survey showing a majority of investors expected to increase their holdings of securities over the next 6 months. In particular a majority also expect equities, of which oil prices tends to be correlated, to provide the biggest returns. These positive indicators were further enhanced by positive sentiment in markets from expectations that the US House of Representatives would pass a bill temporarily suspending the nation’s borrowing limit. Overall WTI climbed 0.9% while Brent increased 0.6%.

Expectations of a supportive result regarding the US debt ceiling were proved correct on Wednesday, with policy makers suspending the debt limit until the 19th May, providing the US with fiscal breathing room for a further few months and thus providing overall positive sentiment to markets on Wednesday. While the news was positive for Brent, an announcement that capacity on the Seaway Pipeline from Cushing was limited due to unforeseen circumstances severely knocked WTI prices, with the grade dropping -1.6%. While the limited capacity will mean further problems for those delivering WTI to Cushing, it also means some refiners may have to cut planned production and so demand may temporarily fall. With Brent increasing 0.4% on the positive US news, the fall in WTI meant a significant rise in the WTI-Brent spread, with the premium of Brent over the US grade increasing $1.90 to $17.6, the highest level in two weeks.

Thursday was another day that saw a combination of strong positives for oil demand expectations, with WTI rising 0.8% and Brent 0.4%. Positive macroeconomic indicators came from both the US and China, which together account for just over 30% of world oil demand. In the US, the weekly initial jobless claims figure fell to the lowest level since January 2008 while the preliminary Chinese manufacturing PMI, a sign of manufacturing strength, rose to 51.9 in January. Coupled with this macroeconomic news was the later than normal weekly EIA inventory data. While overall crude stocks came in higher than expected, the detailed breakdown showed some positive sign for both grades in terms of product demand while falling US net imports was positive news for US produced crude. For more on this see yesterday’s weekly EIA inventory post.

The German Ifo survey, an indication of German executives’ market confidence, increased for the third month running on Friday, while the European Central Bank announced financial institutions will utilise an early repayment opportunity to a greater extent than expected on loans issued from the ECB. While on any other day this news would have resulted in visible gains in the oil markets, a combination of gains throughout the week and overbought signs from technical indicators resulted in traders taking profits instead, and each grade remained stable on Friday. Overall WTI closed the week at $95.9 while Brent reached $113.3.

Week Ahead

Now the House has voted on suspended the federal debt limit for some months, the intensity of market reaction to domestic US political events may take a step down for a few weeks, with macroeconomic demand signs instead taking the main stage. With this in mind, look out for a number of important economic events out of the US this week, with both the advance Q4 2012 GDP number and latest FOMC meeting on Wednesday. Friday also sees the monthly non-farm payrolls release which is perceived as perhaps the most important macroeconomic indicator, providing an indication of economic strength through labour market developments. The ISM manufacturing index shortly after this will also give an indication of how US producers are faring. For a useful summary of these releases and market expectations see this article at Marketnews.com. In addition to this news, WTI is likely to see gains and the WTI-Brent spread narrow when there is confirmation that the Seaway Pipeline capacity is back up, which is expected this week.

Saturday, 26 January 2013

Weekly Inventory Analysis: EIA release of 24th January

Summary of last weeks’ change in Crude Inventories figures:


API: +3.166 mb
EIA Consensus:  +2 mb
EIA actual: +2.8 mb

Note: EIA data was released at 16:00 GMT on Thursday this week due to the US holiday.

An increase of crude inventories of +2.8 mb was more than the market had expected, but with a number of positive details in the breakdown both WTI and Brent saw gains after the initial release. In particular, gasoline stocks and products supplied were both positive for the market, and this release also confirmed the first draw of stocks from Cushing since November in what was the first full week of data available since the expansion of the Seaway Pipeline.  Overall the rise in crude stocks has been primarily due to a fall in refinery input, with both US crude production and imports falling.

The Breakdown

Refinery data showed that producers continued to cut production last week, with utilization falling 4.3 percentage points to 83.6%. While this drop was large, refiners have showed similar low utilisation rates in January in previous years, in line with the build-up of stocks also normally experienced.  This fall in utilisation was reflected by a fall in net crude input of -895,000 b/d, although the data showed refinery production of gasoline continue to rise while distillate production fell.

While input declined as refiners sought to pare the build-up of product stocks, there were positive signs in the demand side data which showed both total petroleum products and in particular gasoline demand had increased for the second week running.  With the increase in gasoline demand resulting in a fall in gasoline stocks by -1.7mb, there were signs that gasoline inventories, which have risen recently to a particularly elevated level, were beginning to plateau.  Hence this news will have been taken positively by the market.

Another positive sign for US produced grades was the fact that net imports continued to fall; this week by a further 301,000 b/d. Net imports are now 771,000 b/d lower than they were at the highest point in December, although the series is perhaps the most volatile of the weekly data.

While increased product demand and decreased imports seem positive for US crude blends, the latest US crude production data also showed a decrease. While the series is also volatile, the small fall of -52,000 b/d could suggest the rate of US production increase is decelerating, which would allow infrastructure providers greater chance to catch up with production that spiked massively in 2012.



How Markets Reacted

Demand signals have been closely watched in the midst of the US economic recovery and political clashes over recent weeks. Thus despite the headline crude number coming in at a higher inventory gain than expected, the positive elements on the demand were met well and both WTI and Brent increased in the period immediately after the EIA report.

WTI, which was priced around $96.60 just before 16:00, saw an immediate fall of 0.10 in the first minute after the release and then moved up to just over $97.70 before traders took profits. The grade then fell to a similar position to its starting point, however this was due to an announcement that the Seaway Pipeline was experiencing capacity problems and thus the ability to get oil from Cushing to refiners on the gulf coast was hampered.

Brent also followed a similar pattern but managed to hold on to its gains. Just before 16:00 the grade was trading at around $112.10, with increases taking the grade up to $112.50 experiencing a short correction and going on to trading in a range. While the grade flirted with the $112.40 line several times in the afternoon, it failed to maintain any gains past what seems be a strong area of technical resistance.

For clarification see the one-minute charts, price in USD cents, below.






Next week’s release

With the Seaway Pipeline operating under restricted capacity for part of this week, the release on Wednesday will show the full effect on inventories at Cushing. Having said this, it is reported some storage in the area is now completely full and so there may be a limit to how much stocks in Cushing itself can increase, with crude simply staying in other parts of the country.

In terms of the overall report, demand side factors will continue to be the main point of interest for markets, with increasing gasoline demand a trend that investors would like to see continue in the coming weeks. With gasoline stocks now plateauing it will be interesting to see if refinery utilization picks up again in this week’s release, although with the presence of the US holiday such a result may have to wait for another week.